Select Page

It's Thanksgiving morning at my house. The crockpot hot chocolate's on, the turkey's been in the cooker for hours, and the whole kitchen smells like butter and sage. Somewhere under a dish towel, my phone buzzes with "running late!" texts.

In a few hours, everyone I love will be squeezed around my table. And I already know we won't all agree on everything.

My kids are young adults now, figuring out what they believe and how they want to live. A few relatives and I have very different ideas about politics. We don't all see the world the same way, and the holidays have a funny way of putting all those views at one table, right next to the mashed potatoes.

For years, I thought a peaceful holiday meant nobody disagreed. These days, I'm finding something a little more realistic, and honestly, a lot more restful.

Peace, Redefined

Here's where I've landed: a peaceful holiday is one where everyone still gets a good meal and a good time together, even if we don't agree on much else. If someone needs to air a grievance, we can do that safely and wrap it up safely. And if we can't, it can wait for another day.

That takes a lot of pressure off the host. I don't have to referee every conversation or get everyone on the same page. Romans 12:18 puts it gently: as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone. My part is how I show up. The rest isn't mine to carry.

On Mute (and Okay with It)

The big conversations rarely happen at the table. In our house, they happen in the kitchen, somewhere between the dishes and the second slice of sweet potato pie or S'mores Cake. The kids are home, everyone's relaxed, and someone starts a sentence with "Remember when you guys made us..."

This is a very normal part of having grown kids. They look back at their childhood with adult eyes, and sometimes they don't agree with the choices we made.

My husband and I started our family right after we married, in our early twenties. We pretty much grew up alongside our kids, and there was plenty of trial and error along the way. I know we did our best. I also know our best wasn't always the wisest call. Discovering that your parents aren't perfect is part of growing up, and it's their turn to figure life out now.

So when one of those kitchen conversations starts to drift sideways, I've started putting myself on mute. Picture a video call where you're nodding thoughtfully with your microphone off. No two cents. No defending. No rushing in to fix it.

It's humbling, and I've made my peace with that. I'd rather be a mom my kids can be honest with than one who looks perfect. James 1:19 has become my unofficial holiday motto: quick to listen, slow to speak. Turns out it pairs nicely with pie.

Reading the Room

Most years I'm the one hosting. Our extended family lives about 3,000 miles away, so some years we're the ones crossing the country with our suitcases, and some years we're catching up by phone between courses. Either way, I've learned the most useful holiday skill isn't carving or making gravy. It's reading the room.

Everyone walks in carrying something: a hard year, an old hurt, a loss nobody's brought up yet. Sometimes the loudest opinion at the table is really pain in disguise. Remembering that helps me hear people out instead of shutting them down.

With the relatives who see the world differently than I do, I usually listen for a bit. If things start heading somewhere unkind, I nudge the conversation elsewhere: a question about their year, a compliment on the baked macaroni and cheese dish, an urgent need for someone to try the pie. I try to stay warm. And if they're just not having it, we let it go. Not every conversation needs to land. Some just need to end.

The Walk-Around-the-Block Rule

Here's one of the most freeing things I've figured out: a hard conversation doesn't have to finish today.

When things get heated, everybody gets room. Someone might need to vent. Someone might need to step outside. Sometimes that someone is me, lacing up my sneakers for a lap around the block. We can always come back to it later, once we've cooled off and nobody's hangry or running on four hours of sleep. Never underestimate what a nap and a plate of leftovers can do for a conversation.

Back-Pocket Phrases

  • To listen: "Tell me more. I want to understand where you're coming from."
  • To pause: "I want to hear this, and I don't want to rush it. Can we pick it up tomorrow?"
  • To redirect: "Okay, catch me up on your year. What's been the best part?"
  • To step away: "I'm grabbing some air. Be right back."
  • To close it kindly: "We might not land in the same place, and I'm so glad you're here."

By the Time the Pie Is Gone

By evening, the leftovers are packed into mismatched containers, somebody's asleep on the couch (usually my husband), and the kitchen finally goes quiet. We didn't agree on everything today. We didn't have to.

The table was still full. The food was still good. And love turned out to be bigger than any one conversation.

You don't have to win the argument to keep the peace. Just do your part, and trust God with the rest.

Before Your Next Gathering

Grab your journal and sit with these for a few minutes:

  • What would a peaceful holiday honestly look like for me this year?
  • Which conversation am I bracing for, and how could I listen instead of defend?
  • Where do I need to give myself permission to step away?

Now It's Your Turn

How do you keep the peace when your family doesn't see eye to eye? Share what's worked for you in the comments. Your words might be exactly what another mom needs this season.

And for more conversations like this one, subscribe to the Christian Moms Café newsletter and listen to the podcast.

Website | + posts

Demetria is the founder and Editor-in-Chief of "Christian Moms Café, bringing over two decades in digital media and podcasting to a space built on grace over guilt. Beyond the cafe, she coaches podcasters through her agency, Soul Podcasting Collective, and teaches piano lessons over Zoom. She lives in the San Francisco Bay Area with her husband and their Shih Tzu, while her two adult daughters are off building their own lives — one still away at college. In her spare time, you’ll find her writing songs, leading worship at church, holed up in a San Francisco café with a good book, or hiking the foggy hills of the East Bay.