Every Thanksgiving, somewhere between the rolls and the second helping of stuffing, it happens. Someone clears their throat and says, "Okay, let's go around the table. What's everybody thankful for?"
And every year, I have two answers ready. There's the one I say out loud: my family, my home, the food in front of us. All true. Then there's the one I keep tucked away. The one that sounds more like, I'm thankful, and this year has been hard.
For a long time, I thought the second answer canceled out the first. That being grateful meant pretending everything was fine.
I don't believe that anymore.

The Answer I Don't Say Out Loud
Here's the part I usually keep to myself: our family has been through a season of real financial difficulty.
From the outside, you might not notice. We have some things in place that keep life looking steady. But behind the scenes, we've had to hunker down and trust God for our next everything: our next resources, our next opportunities, our next step. Even when the money was looking funny. Especially then.
It was a lonely season. I didn't feel like anyone would truly understand, so for a while my only real conversations about it were with God and with a therapist. (If you've ever needed both, you're in good company. I'm grateful for each.)
And money wasn't the only weight. We're still healing from losing my mother-in-law in 2020, and in the past year and a half, we've also said goodbye to a cousin and an aunt. Grief has a way of pulling up a chair at the holidays whether you invite it or not.
Then there's our health. Several of us in the family, me included, have been dealing with health concerns. We're working through them together with our doctors, one appointment and one test result at a time.
So when someone asks what I'm thankful for, the honest answer is complicated. But here's what surprised me: even in the hardest stretch, I kept finding pockets of gratitude. Not instead of the hard things. Right alongside them.
In Everything, Not For Everything
"In every thing give thanks: for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus concerning you." (1 Thessalonians 5:18, KJV)
I used to read this verse as a test I was failing. Be thankful for everything? For the bills, the losses, the closed doors?
Then I noticed the little word Paul actually used. In. In every thing. Not for every thing. God isn't asking me to be grateful for grief or for a stretched budget. He's inviting me to give thanks in the middle of them, because He's there too.
We live in a very expensive part of the country, and more than once I've wondered whether we should just pack up and go somewhere easier. But I believe God brought us here for a purpose, and that if He wants us somewhere else, He'll make a way. All through this season, I kept hearing the same quiet words: Hold still. Hold on. Don't go anywhere or do anything unless I tell you to.
It reminded me of Moses at the edge of the Red Sea: "The LORD shall fight for you, and ye shall hold your peace" (Exodus 14:14, KJV).
So I held still. And holding still taught me to be grateful for things I never would have put on a list. Every job opportunity. Every time I heard no after an interview, even when it stung. And every yes door He opened, including the ones I'm walking through right now: this magazine and our podcast.
God isn't asking me to be grateful for grief. He's inviting me to give thanks in the middle of it, because He's there too.
The Table I Have
These days, getting all four of us around one table doesn't happen often. The kids are off at college and living their own adult lives, so when everyone's home at once, I notice. I notice the noise, the extra dishes, the inside jokes I'm only half in on.
After the losses of these past few years, I look around that table differently. There's sadness for the faces I know I'll never see again. But there's also deep gratitude for the family we've been able to hold onto.
I'm grateful for the repair, too. Like any family, we've had our share of communication breakdowns and disagreements. But I've learned to treasure the moments after, when someone reaches out first, the air clears, and we find our way back to each other.
And I'm grateful for the small, everyday pleasures that kept me going when the bigger picture felt heavy:
- a walk outside, and whatever nature decides to show me that day
- a good cup of tea in the morning
- long conversations with friends and colleagues
- trying something new in my community, just because I can
None of these erased the financial pressure or the grief. They didn't have to. They just reminded me that God was still giving good gifts, even in a lean season.
Try This: The "And" List
Here's what's been helping me. I keep a gratitude journal: a beautiful Hosanna Revival journal my daughter brought home for me from a church summer camp a few years ago. I try to fill one page a day. Some days the page overflows. Other days it takes everything in me to find enough to write. Either way, showing up to that page keeps me practicing.

If gratitude feels hard to reach this year, try this. Grab your journal (or the back of a grocery receipt) and finish a few sentences like these:
- I'm grateful for ___, and I'm tired of ___.
- I'm grateful for ___, and I miss ___.
- I'm grateful for ___, and I'm still waiting on God for ___.
Both halves are true. You don't have to choose. Saying them side by side is a kind of honesty that makes room for real thankfulness, not the forced kind.
Two more small ways to practice:
- One honest line a day. If a full page feels like too much, start here. Before bed, write one thing you're thankful for and one thing you're carrying. That's it. No gratitude jar required.
- Send one thank-you text. Think of someone who quietly carried you this year, and tell them. It'll take two minutes and might make their whole week.

Back at the Table
This Thanksgiving, when the go-around question comes, I'll probably still say the out-loud answer: my family, my home, the food in front of us. It's true, and I mean every word.
But I won't pretend the other answer isn't there. I'm thankful, and this year has been hard. Both can sit at the table. God has room for both.
If your answer is complicated this year too, you're not doing gratitude wrong. You're just being honest. And honest gratitude might be the truest kind there is.
Before You Pass the Pie
Take a few quiet minutes with your journal before the big day:
- What would my honest answer be this year, both halves?
- Where have I found a pocket of gratitude in a hard season?
- Who carried me this year, and how can I thank them?
Now It's Your Turn
What's on your "And" list this year? Share one line in the comments, as much or as little as you'd like. Someone else may need to know they're not the only one.
And for more honest conversations like this one, subscribe to the Christian Moms Café newsletter and listen to the podcast.
Demetria is the founder and Editor-in-Chief of "Christian Moms Café, bringing over two decades in digital media and podcasting to a space built on grace over guilt. Beyond the cafe, she coaches podcasters through her agency, Soul Podcasting Collective, and teaches piano lessons over Zoom. She lives in the San Francisco Bay Area with her husband and their Shih Tzu, while her two adult daughters are off building their own lives — one still away at college. In her spare time, you’ll find her writing songs, leading worship at church, holed up in a San Francisco café with a good book, or hiking the foggy hills of the East Bay.



